8-Hour Schedules vs. 12-Hour Schedules: Pros and Cons
Pros of 8-hour Shift Schedules
- More traditional hours
- More time for daily activities after work
- Easier to cover vacations and absences
- More direct communication with management
- More flexibility for training, overtime, etc.
Cons of 8-hour Shift Schedules
- Increased turnovers and rotations
- Maximum consecutive days worked
- Minimum days off
- Minimum weekends off
- Rotations too fast for biological adjustment
- Required evening shift
- Strained family and social life
Pros of 12-hour Shift Schedules
- Increased number of days and weekends off
- Fewer consecutive shifts
- More frequent breaks
- Longer breaks
- Increased rest/recovery time
- Fewer shift turnovers and rotations
- Better communication between shift crews
- Reciprocity of shift turnover
- Opportunity for more productive maintenance
- Higher quality social and family time off
- More popular with shiftworkers and families
- Reduced absenteeism
- Lower attrition and turnover
- Eliminates evening shift
- Reduces travel time and commuting costs
- Eliminates double shifts/holdovers
- Allows better use of vacation time
- Has little effect on overtime
- Does not require additional staffing
- No more physiologically difficult than 8-hour shifts for most jobs
Cons of 12-hour Shift Schedules
- Coverage for vacations and absences must be better managed
- Sometimes more difficult for older workers
- Potential ergonomics risks with physically strenuous jobs
- Management communication less convenient
- Possibility of irregular pay weeks
- Little time off on days worked for other activities
- Potential child care conflicts/domestic conflicts
- Reduced flexibility for training, overtime, etc.
- Less flexibility in scheduling meetings
- More lost pay for day missed
- Requires sleep schedule adjustments
- Complex to change from 8's
Back Home